Prior to her career in education, Shelley worked as the School-to-Work Coordinator for the Construction Industry Corporation, a Gender Equity Consultant for the Illinois State Board of Education, the Education and Development Director at Chicago Women in the Trades, and held various positions at Women Employed. Shelley has a BA from Western Washington University and an MA from the University of Chicago. She completed courses leading to teacher certification at DePaul University at the age of 40.
Shelley has lived with her family in Evanston for 30 years. Her two daughters attended King Arts and ETHS. She was active on the Board of Directors of the YWCA Evanston/North Shore for several years, including a stint as Board Chair.